James Miller, Portfolio Manager
How can Treasury Wine Estates report cashflow of $27m and profit of $219m? Should we be concerned?
One of the joys of analysing investment opportunities is that every opportunity is unique. In making investment decisions, we look at each company through a slightly different lens. During the February reporting season one of the key issues that arose was the mismatch between cashflow and earnings for many companies. In the article below we explore why this happens, and how it affects our decision making.
There are three key areas to focus on:
- What drives the difference between cashflow and earnings?
- When should you be concerned?
- How does it affect our decision making?
We conclude that recurring or deteriorating cashflow issues may be symptomatic of a broader issue in the business. In our Absolute Return Strategy, poor cashflow can be a red flag for further research of potential short opportunities.
1. What drives the differences between cashflow and earnings?
Changes in working capital can often explain the key differences between operating cashflow and earnings. Key drags on cashflow for a company can be:
- Increasing receivables – a company is yet to be paid from customers
- Reducing payables – suppliers being paid quicker by the company
- Increasing inventory – a company is yet to sell goods they have produced
Ideally you have high payables, low inventory and low receivables. The combination means a company is getting paid quickly, for goods you recently produced, and not having to pay your suppliers quickly.
2. When should you be concerned?
Cashflow is a concern if you believe that the company isn’t going to receive that cash at some point in the future. Two companies that had poor cashflow conversion in the Dec 18 half were engineering firm Worley Parsons and wine exporter, Treasury Wine Estates. Cash conversion is a ratio of operating cashflow to accounting earnings – the higher the better.
We weren’t concerned in February 19 when Worley Parsons announced operating cashflow of $21m versus profit of $98m. For companies with skinny margins and large revenues, such as Worley Parsons, a small move in timing of receivables or payables can have large effects on cashflow. To put it in context, in that 6-month period Worley had ~$2.6b of cash receipts from customers and paid nearly $2.6b in payments to suppliers. Put simply, the scale of the cashflows in and out of the company during the period were large compared to the profit, so a couple of days change in payment timing can make all the difference.
One result that warrants more research was Treasury Wine Estates (TWE). Management went to the effort of explaining that, whilst their 31 December 2018 cash conversion was just 54%, at the end of January this had stepped up to 85%. A possible explanation of changes in cash conversion is the timing of sales. One key question that springs to mind is whether Treasury’s customers have been receiving better payment terms to get sales completed in the half year?
For the contracting sector (think companies like Cimic, Monadelphous and Lend Lease) poor cashflow always requires investigation. The first sign of a large construction contract encountering problems is often the customer stopping or slowing payments to the contractor until the problem is rectified. Given that the profit on construction contracts is recognised by a management assessment of completion progress, the profit can be more subjective than the cashflow.
3. How does it affect our decision making?
Earnings are the key metric we use to assess most companies. Earnings are far less volatile than cashflow and enable the best comparison for valuation between companies on a timely basis. For example, doing cross-industry comparison, we can compare banks (with very messy cashflows) to resource companies effectively using earnings as the primary metric.
However, understanding a business’s cashflow is also critically important. Typically, a short-term hiccup in cashflow, that is well explained by management, is not a concern. But recurring poor cashflow, or deteriorating cashflows in certain industries, can be a warning sign.
Making investment decisions involves looking at many aspects of a company’s financial position. One critical component is understanding a company’s cashflow. Recurring or deteriorating cashflow issues may be symptomatic of a broader issue in the business. In our Absolute Return Strategy, poor cashflow can be a red flag for further research of potential short opportunities.
Firetrail Investments Pty Limited ABN 98 622 377 913 (‘Firetrail’), Corporate Authorised Representative (No. 1261372) of Pinnacle Investment Management Limited ABN 66 109 659 109 AFSL 322140.
Any opinions or forecasts reflect the judgment and assumptions of Firetrail and its representatives on the basis of information at the date of publication and may later change without notice. Any projections contained in this article are estimates only and may not be realised in the future. The information is not intended as a securities recommendation or statement of opinion intended to influence a person or persons in making a decision in relation to investment. This communication is for general information only. It has been prepared without taking account of any person’s objectives, financial situation or needs. Any persons relying on this information should obtain professional advice relevant to their particular circumstances, needs and investment objectives. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance.
Interests in the Firetrail Absolute Return Fund (ARSN 624 135 879) and Firetrail Australian High Conviction Fund (ARSN 624 136 045) (‘Funds’) are issued by Pinnacle Fund Services Limited ABN 29 082 494 362 AFSL 238371. Pinnacle Fund Services Limited is not licensed to provide financial product advice. A copy of the most recent Product Disclosure Statement (‘PDS’) of the Funds can be located at www.firetrail.com You should consider the current PDS in its entirety and consult your financial adviser before making an investment decision.
Pinnacle Fund Services Limited and Firetrail believe the information contained in this communication is reliable, however its accuracy, reliability or completeness is not guaranteed and persons relying on this information do so at their own risk. Subject to any liability which cannot be excluded under the relevant laws, Firetrail and Pinnacle Fund Services Limited disclaim all liability to any person relying on the information contained in this communication in respect of any loss or damage (including consequential loss or damage), however caused, which may be suffered or arise directly or indirectly in respect of such information.